About Us

Will Marshall Insurance Brokers in Barrie and Orillia is proud to be family owned and operated.

Will Marshall Insurance Broker’s mission is to provide insurance advice, advocacy, integrity and dependability - which make a difference.

In 1983, Will Marshall, working at the Simcoe District Co-Op in Barrie, left his eleven-year administrative position to join in a partnership with his brother, Douglas G. Marshall, as a registered insurance broker in the city of Orillia. Will’s long term goal was to grow the Orillia office and expand into other areas of Simcoe County.

In 1989, Will incorporated Will Marshall Insurance Brokers and, in 1991, amalgamated the Orillia office under the same corporate name. Many of the relationships Will made during his sojourn with Simcoe District Co-Op formed the foundation of our brokerage today. Will’s passion in his new environment contributed to the ongoing success of his brokerage.

Why Will Marshall?

For over 35 years, we’ve worked diligently to build long-lasting and trustworthy relationships with our clients that are not just professional, but are personal and unique to the needs of each individual client. At Will Marshall Insurance Brokers, our clients are more than a random policy number. They are real people whom we want the best for; our neighbours, friends and family.

The team at Will Marshall aims to offer each and every client with exceptional service, ensuring all insurance options and/or concerns are addressed and thoroughly explained. We want your experience to be a pleasant one, and we’re confident our customer service and professionalism will provide you with just that.

We truly value your business, and we’re dedicated to carefully doing whatever it takes to earn it year after year.

Will Marshall Insurance Brokers give you a peace of mind.

Advice

An insurance professional has experience and education you can count on for a better decision-making process.

Advocacy

Brokers represent the client first and the company second. Brokers provide unbiased information to clients and hold the insurance company accountable whenever necessary.

Integrity

Doing the right thing when no one is looking. Brokers are held to a higher duty of care than direct writers or insurance agents.

Dependability

Our brokerage is available and continues to support our clients. Call our office and you are greeted by a person, not a computer.

I cannot say enough about Stephanie Siegel of Will Marshall Insurance. She is ethical, reliable and will go to bat for her clients when you most need it. If you are in need of home or auto insurance, her wealth of knowledge will most certainly benefit you.

I’ve purchased my insurance here for 10 years and I’ve always had nothing but an incredible experience dealing with the talented and highly professional staff at Will Marshall.

I was particularly impressed how Mike took the time to personally consult with me, to learn about my specific home and auto insurance requirements and by his willingness to answer all of my questions about potential new policy providers. Thanks to Mike, I have saved almost 40% on my home and auto insurance coverage costs!

I’ve never had such amazing, personable service in my life. Colin goes out of his way to make sure my insurance needs are met. They are always there exactly when I need them. Absolutely the BEST!