Exceptional Insurance Service Since 1983
Will Marshall Insurance Brokers is family-owned and operated - and you'll love the difference that makes.
Automobile
Residential
Business
Farm
Recreational
Will Marshall built a brokerage by putting the client first.
We make insurance easy by giving you the knowledge to choose the best option.
As your insurance advocates, we’re here to guide you when making coverage decisions, coverage changes, or when you need help after a claim. We leverage years of experience as well as our close relationships with insurance companies and vendors to protect our clients better.
Working tirelessly for our clients, we have built a reputation of integrity.
You’re at the centre of our business, and you’ll see that reflected in our service.
Insurance means not having to worry about the “what if.” Instead, you’ll be able to focus on what’s important now.
Contact our office today to get started.
Insurance Partners
Treating You Like Family Since 1983
What Our Customers Say About Us
Nabil S.
16:49 30 Mar 26
Mike Shepherd super knowledgable and great to deal with always gets us the best rates. We have commercial insurance and personal insurance with him and he’s always just a phone call away when you really need him anytime a day!
John H.
00:29 10 Sep 24
Cassandra is wonderful and takes good care of me when I need her. I have been with Will Marshall for over 45 years always good service from everyone there.
Carol M.
18:21 09 Aug 24
Jim T.
16:34 29 Jul 24
Morra L.
15:20 09 May 24
We used WMI to broker our business insurance 2 years ago.
We couldn't be happier with the great service and friendly staff.
Special thanks to Mike Sheppard. From what I've seen, he is the best broker in Ontario!
We couldn't be happier with the great service and friendly staff.
Special thanks to Mike Sheppard. From what I've seen, he is the best broker in Ontario!
Arron G.
19:14 19 Mar 24
I have been working with Mike Shepherd here and I cannot speak highly enough of Mike's expertise and dedication in the field of insurance. Mike possesses an unparalleled understanding of the intricacies of insurance, and his commitment to ensuring your protection is truly commendable. He consistently offers valuable insights on safeguarding yourself, your loved ones, and your assets, often highlighting aspects that might otherwise be overlooked.
One of Mike's standout qualities is his generosity with his time. He willingly goes the extra mile to help you comprehend the complexities of your insurance landscape, even when dealing with policies from different companies. Recently, I sought Mike's assistance with an insurance challenge involving a separate company, and his support exceeded all expectations. Mike not only clarified the details of my policy but also provided numerous suggestions, ultimately guiding me towards achieving my desired outcomes.
Mike is more than a knowledgeable professional; he is a trusted advisor and a reliable assistant in navigating the intricate world of insurance. I wholeheartedly recommend him for any inquiries or discussions related to insurance. With Mike, you can be confident that you have a dedicated ally who prioritizes your understanding and peace of mind.
One of Mike's standout qualities is his generosity with his time. He willingly goes the extra mile to help you comprehend the complexities of your insurance landscape, even when dealing with policies from different companies. Recently, I sought Mike's assistance with an insurance challenge involving a separate company, and his support exceeded all expectations. Mike not only clarified the details of my policy but also provided numerous suggestions, ultimately guiding me towards achieving my desired outcomes.
Mike is more than a knowledgeable professional; he is a trusted advisor and a reliable assistant in navigating the intricate world of insurance. I wholeheartedly recommend him for any inquiries or discussions related to insurance. With Mike, you can be confident that you have a dedicated ally who prioritizes your understanding and peace of mind.
Cacao S.
23:28 10 Jan 24
My golly what lovely people.
Thank you Carol Lynn Galati for all the help with my shenanigans.
Thank you to everyone who I have spoken too on the phone for dealing with me being a grump 🙂
Safe Travels!
Thank you Carol Lynn Galati for all the help with my shenanigans.
Thank you to everyone who I have spoken too on the phone for dealing with me being a grump 🙂
Safe Travels!
Garret S.
23:24 30 Nov 23
These guys have been amazing! Always answer the phones and respond promptly when they say they will. Never in my life woukd I want to deal with another brokerage. Mike is awesome!
Leigh R.
15:52 24 May 23
I am delighted to be able to work with Will Marshall Insurance brokers. They are one of the last family owned brokerages in area so I am happy to support them. In particular Megan Trainor is an awesome agent . She is knowledgeable , attentive and provides excellent advice. I look forward to working with her !
Greg M.
15:44 16 May 23
I worked with this company for years. This year I was shopping around and Will Marshall could not beat the quote I was given by another company, so I cancelled at the end of April and told them I did not need coverage as of May 1. No issues -EXCEPT a May 1 payment came out of my account. I contacted them for a refund was told to wait 12- 15 days.
UPDATE - Will Marshall did follow up with me and was able to resolve my issue. In fairness, I have updated my review rating for them. They did come through in the end.
UPDATE - Will Marshall did follow up with me and was able to resolve my issue. In fairness, I have updated my review rating for them. They did come through in the end.
Dorothy R.
04:55 20 Dec 19
I highly recommend Mike Shepherd at Will Marshall Insurance Brokers. He is highly knowledgeable about all aspects of the insurance industry. I was particularly impressed how Mike took the time to personally consult with me, to learn about my specific home and auto insurance requirements and by his willingness to answer all of my questions about potential new policy providers. Thanks to Mike, I have saved almost 40% on my home and auto insurance coverage costs!
Recent News
What Happens if Someone Else Is Driving Your Car and Crashes in Ontario
Lending your car to a friend, family member, or even a coworker is something many drivers in Ontario do without thinking twice. Whether it is
What First Time ATV Riders in Orillia Should Know About Recreational Insurance
All terrain vehicle riding is a popular way to explore the outdoors in Orillia and across Simcoe County. With access to nearby trails, cottage country
Why Choosing the Right Home Insurance Matters for Barrie Homeowners
Owning a home is one of the biggest investments a person can make. For a Barrie homeowner, protecting that investment goes beyond regular maintenance or
Associations and Charities
